7
133 Church St, Bowmanville, ON L1C 2Z4, Canada
Bowmanville, Ontario L1C 2Z4
+19056974444

Ordered online. Showed up 20 minutes later for pick up. Still wasnt ready. Waited another 25 minutes. Was not busy. I was the only one there. Not sure why the hold up. I ordered the cup and crisp. The pizza I received was nothing like the one advertised. The pepperoni were tiny. Again, looks nothing like the picture. I ordered it well done, it was not. The garlic crust was gross. There was way WAY too much cheese on it. The sauce was disgusting.

Online order from bowmanville order number 6559. Tried contacting the store to make them aware this was the worst tasting pizza ever made. 6 teenagers and more than half the pizza left. That says it all. Disgusting. Normally this location is very good. Not today. Waste of $45. Feel free to make it right. Order number will give you the full info of the online order and location.

We’ve ordered from here for years. Not sure what has happened. As soon as we opened the pizza box, I noticed it looked different. Something has changed, different brand of cheese or sauce or something, the crust was cardboard like, hardly any cheese. Very disappointing.

Ordered a party size pepperoni and it tasted like a really bad frozen pizza. Sour/salty sauce, undercooked and cheap pepperoni toppings. I was really excited for this pizza.

The girl that seems to always be working was in and she's awesome at her job. (Im sorry I dont know her name but ordered on Sunday Sept 4th) She is friendly, quick and can definitely work well under pressure! We love Square Boys. Use to go there for lunch dates and now go back for family dinner!

I used to love square boys, but they have gone downhill. I ordered an XL three topping pizza, green pepper, onion and ham. They messed up my pizza, which is what it is, it happens. I called and they gave me a free large pizza. We ordered again but told me they can’t get a delivery driver because it’s too far, I live in Courtice, 8km away from square boys. So proceed to order the large pizza with three toppings, like my last pizza and get to the store to find out I owe for the toppings… and it was poorly prepared. Needless to say I won’t be going here again.

Highly disappointing experience. Delivery took 2 hours, forgot 2 of the bread items and a dip. Forgot the crust flavour. They offered me a credit but since I am travelling couldn’t accept.

Show Map

Square Boy Pizza & Subs — Pizza restaurant in Bowmanville

We are glad to greet you!

Square Boy Pizza & Subs

Pizza restaurant at 133 Church St, Bowmanville, ON L1C 2Z4, Canada. Here you will find detailed information about Square Boy Pizza & Subs: address, phone, fax, opening hours, customer reviews, photos, directions and more.

Opening hours

  • Sunday
    11 AM–9 PM
  • Monday
    11 AM–10 PM
  • Tuesday
    11 AM–10 PM
  • Wednesday
    11 AM–10 PM
  • Thursday
    11 AM–11 PM
  • Friday
    11 AM–11 PM
  • Saturday
    11 AM–11 PM

Rating

2
/
5
Based on 7 reviews

Contacts

Categories:
State:
Ontario
Address:
133 Church St, Bowmanville, ON L1C 2Z4, Canada.
City:
Bowmanville
Phone:
Postcode:
L1C 2Z4

About Square Boy Pizza & Subs

Square Boy Pizza & Subs is a Canadian Pizza restaurant based in Bowmanville, Ontario. Square Boy Pizza & Subs is located at 133 Church St, Bowmanville, ON L1C 2Z4, Canada.


Please contact with Square Boy Pizza & Subs using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Square Boy Pizza & Subs opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.

Are you the owner?
You can make a change to the page:
Edit this page

ALL reviews about Square Boy Pizza & Subs

  • Andy BoBandy
    Added 2025.10.01
    Ordered online. Showed up 20 minutes later for pick up. Still wasnt ready. Waited another 25 minutes. Was not busy. I was the only one there. Not sure why the hold up. I ordered the cup and crisp. The pizza I received was nothing like the one advertised. The pepperoni were tiny. Again, looks nothing like the picture. I ordered it well done, it was not. The garlic crust was gross. There was way WAY too much cheese on it. The sauce was disgusting.
  • David P
    Added 2025.08.28
    Online order from bowmanville order number 6559. Tried contacting the store to make them aware this was the worst tasting pizza ever made. 6 teenagers and more than half the pizza left. That says it all. Disgusting. Normally this location is very good. Not today. Waste of $45. Feel free to make it right. Order number will give you the full info of the online order and location.
  • Erin S.
    Added 2025.08.22
    We’ve ordered from here for years. Not sure what has happened. As soon as we opened the pizza box, I noticed it looked different. Something has changed, different brand of cheese or sauce or something, the crust was cardboard like, hardly any cheese. Very disappointing.
  • scappa 10
    Added 2025.06.08
    Ordered a party size pepperoni and it tasted like a really bad frozen pizza. Sour/salty sauce, undercooked and cheap pepperoni toppings. I was really excited for this pizza.
  • Lindsey Rose
    Added 2022.09.05
    The girl that seems to always be working was in and she's awesome at her job. (Im sorry I dont know her name but ordered on Sunday Sept 4th) She is friendly, quick and can definitely work well under pressure! We love Square Boys. Use to go there for lunch dates and now go back for family dinner!
  • By owner
    Added 2022.09.05
    Thank you for your review ..Emma is her name and she is the store owner
  • Collin D'Antimo
    Added 2022.03.27
    I used to love square boys, but they have gone downhill. I ordered an XL three topping pizza, green pepper, onion and ham. They messed up my pizza, which is what it is, it happens. I called and they gave me a free large pizza. We ordered again but told me they can’t get a delivery driver because it’s too far, I live in Courtice, 8km away from square boys. So proceed to order the large pizza with three toppings, like my last pizza and get to the store to find out I owe for the toppings… and it was poorly prepared. Needless to say I won’t be going here again.
  • By owner
    Added 2022.03.27
    We will reach out to the store and find out what happened ..I would not be normal for the store to charge for only toppings on a pizza they made a mistake on.. We have reached out to the store and they will apply a full credit for a XL 3 topping and again we are sorry for the mistakes with your order Regards
  • B G
    Added 2021.07.05
    Highly disappointing experience. Delivery took 2 hours, forgot 2 of the bread items and a dip. Forgot the crust flavour. They offered me a credit but since I am travelling couldn’t accept.
  • By owner
    Added 2021.07.05
    We are very sorry and will reveiw tonight to see what changes need to be made to improve service.??
Leave your own review about Square Boy Pizza & Subs:
Add a review

You Might Also Consider

Pizza Nova
Pizza restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
2377 Durham Regional Hwy 2, Bowmanville, ON L1C 5A5, Canada.
Little Caesars Pizza
Pizza restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
243 King St E, Bowmanville, ON L1C 5C4, Canada.
Free Topping Pizza
Pizza restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
210 King St E, Bowmanville, ON L1C 1P3, Canada.
Al's Famous Pizza
Pizza restaurant in Ontario
7 reviews
1550 Bowmanville Ave Unit #2, Bowmanville, ON L1C 6N5, Canada.